Is sustainability a luxury for the wealthier?

Is sustainability a luxury?

I have been thinking about my personal finances a lot, lately.
I dedicated the whole of February to money wisdom. I worked out that I have about 25 years (everything going well) of working life still in front of me, and I want to ensure I reach my golden years in a comfortable enough position to enjoy them.
By observing my spending habits more closely, I realised that many of my choices could be defined as ‘first world’.

I’m a minimalist and I’m not a fan of shopping for the sake of it. But my sustainability drive takes me to my local zero-waste shop often to find products without plastic packaging. Generally speaking, I refuse to support an economy that uses an enormous amount of energy to dig rotten dinosaurs and transform them into something that gets used for ten minutes, then thrown away only to hang around in the oceans for hundreds of years.

Sustainable products, however, come at a premium.

Loose pasta, rice, soap, toothpaste, nuts cost more if bought from a local, small independent business which has its heart in the right place, than from your big supermarket.

As we well know, supermarkets buy in much bigger wholesale bulks at lower prices, that impose outrageously low prices on farmers (recently, Italian streets have been inundated by litres of milk by farmers protesting about the low prices imposed on them by supermarkets). Supermarkets don’t necessarily stock the most sustainable, ethical products, and have a lot more wriggle room than the small shops in the way they manage their overheads.

Conscious consumers face a conundrum between ethical and economic choices.

And that’s not just about groceries. The same choices have to be made for fashion purchases: the documentary ‘The True Cost’ tells the terrible story of how cheap, fast fashion clothes are produced, and of how the price of clothing has been decreasing for decades, whilst human and environmental costs have grown dramatically.

Tough choices extend to construction, where numerous studies have been carried out to establish how much more sustainable building costs, and the average is between 2% and 12%, depending mainly on location.

So what is the solution for those that want to live as sustainably as possible without breaking the bank?

 

The solution is the most sustainable choice of all: not buying. Not building. Not doing.

 

Before you start having a go at me, think about it: sustainability unfortunately still is a premium choice.

In the majority of cases, this is because:

a) It currently costs more to produce any product sustainably (that includes fair and ethical production and trading, higher quality materials / ingredients, choice of environmentally friendly packaging, smaller batches, new production processes, slower / artisan production, and so on);

b) Sustainable products give the perception of a finer lifestyle, of niche, higher quality products, which as such, have a higher price tag attached.

In this perspective, choosing not to buy, not to build new, and to reuse or make do instead, are much better options than buying sustainable products.

OK, I can’t make my own rice or lentils, but I can certainly make my own house cleaning products (vinegar and lemon being my preferred choice of ingredients), and many other consumables. In the past I have made my own pasta, stock cubes, clothes, lip balms, moisturisers, shampoo, toothpaste, gifts, baby products and toys from pre-loved baby clothes…and I promise, I’m not wonder woman.

Making do and getting creative with what you already have and buying only a few essential items produced sustainably which last a long time or are of higher quality (or better still, second hand items where possible) is, to me, a much better choice for the planet – and your wallet.

Likewise, in construction, refurbishing, re-purposing, retrofitting and reusing are pretty much always better choices than building new, both from environmental and economic points of view. Less virgin materials, less waste and shorter construction times make refurbishment attractive when the existing structures are sound and the future uses are compatible with them.

Of course, bad refurbishments can also have a significant impact on the environment. But there are a few choices that can be made to ensure the refurbishment is as sustainable as possible. These include (and this is not an exhaustive list):

Choosing low embodied carbon materials and solutions, recycled and reused materials;Thinking about ease of maintenance of elements of the building that will likely last for decades, to avoid replacing them often, e.g. facades;Choosing durable materials for structural elements, like roofs and external envelopes;Thinking about flexibility of internal spaces and location of mechanical and electrical elements for ease of access and maintenance;Generally speaking, considering the life cycle of the refurbished elements.

Up to this point, I might not have written things that are particularly ground-breaking or revolutionary, and probably the old mantra ‘reduce, reuse, recycle’ has popped up in your head right now.

But still today, believe it or not, it is not always so obvious in the commercial world we live in.

In this respect, I invite you to read a great article published on dezeen.com about the new IKEA store in Greenwich, London, claimed by the Swedish retail giant to be its greenest yet.

The article brilliantly opens with: knocking down one sustainable building to build another is nonsensical.

This IKEA store has been built by knocking down the Stirling Prize shortlisted Sainsbury’s Greenwich supermarket, the first ever supermarket achieving a BREEAM Excellent certification. Sainsbury’s Greenwich was an amazing sustainable building built only 17 years before being knocked down, designed by the late Paul Hinkin, when he was working for Chetwoods Architects.

What a waste of resources, intellectual and material efforts, money and carbon dioxide.

So, yes, sustainability seems to be a luxury for the wealthier but it doesn’t have to be.

The most sustainable choices are often the cheapest, most boring, simple and less actionable ones.

You have no rights to post comments

The Green Gorilla's Posts

  • All
  • Coaching
  • Getting Started
  • Resilience
  • SustainABLE Mastermind
  • Womeninsustainability
  • Your Community
  • I have never considered myself a feminist. Not in the extreme sense of the term anyway. Although I have always advocated for equality of opportunities for everyone, whichever sex they identify with, I never contemplated burning my bra. I even
    Read More
    • Resilience
    • Womeninsustainability
    • Your Community
  • The power of resilience in uncertain times

    The power of resilience in uncertain times

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2020-08-03 09:55:52
    I will echo many other people saying that we are living unprecedented times. Life as we know it has come to a weird standstill. Bars, restaurants and shops are starting to reopen after the pandemic, schools and offices have moved
    Read More
    • Coaching
    • Resilience
    • SustainABLE Mastermind
  • Is sustainability a luxury?

    Is sustainability a luxury for the wealthier?

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2019-03-01 09:55:52
    I have been thinking about my personal finances a lot, lately.I dedicated the whole of February to money wisdom. I worked out that I have about 25 years (everything going well) of working life still in front of me, and
    Read More
  • Using science to influence sustainability clients
    If you have children, you might have heard about oxytocin, aka the “happy hormone”, which is released when you bond with your newborn baby, and is even injected into expecting mothers to induce labour. Oxytocin is produced after any emotional
    Read More
  • Using storytelling in technical situations
    A few years ago, in a quest to refurbish a 1960 concrete block on the BRE site in the most innovative and sustainable way possible, I had the good fortune to meet an extraordinary man and architect. He was one
    Read More
  • What is sustainable architecture?

    What does sustainable architecture really mean?

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2018-11-15 09:55:52
    I was recently invited to deliver a CPD session on Sustainable Design at a small architectural studio. I was told beforehand that the office didn't specifically look at sustainability in their practices, as it was a small practice. In my
    Read More
  • Can circular economy save the planet?

    Can circular economy save the planet?

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2018-11-15 09:55:52
    This phrase by Walter Stahel, the man who also coined the phrase ‘cradle to cradle’, made me chuckle before I felt the heaviness of its meaning. How often do we actually feel that our single and collective actions have an
    Read More
  • The difficulty of selling sustaiability

    Why aren’t your clients interested in sustainability?

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2018-11-15 09:55:52
    I’ve been asking myself this question over and over again: why aren’t clients interested in sustainability? A couple of months ago, my eight-year-old daughter told me off because we were still using plastic toothbrushes. I’m a sustainability consultant, and sustainability
    Read More
  • Selling sustainability to your co-workers
    It’s another day in the office. Fights over the stapler, ‘elevenses’ gossip, passive-aggressive comments hissed in between the teeth, boiling in silence because your colleague is on Facebook while you are slaving away, talking to the boss instead of having
    Read More
  • The top five skills of a sustainability consultant

    The top five skills of a sustainability consultant

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2018-10-28 09:55:52
    It was all over the national news a couple of weeks ago: according to a new assessment from IPCC, limiting global warming to 1.5ºC would require rapid, far-reaching and unprecedented changes in all aspects of society. One of the key
    Read More
  • Women and the construction industry

    Why doesn't Wonder Woman wear a hard hat?

    By Virginia Cinquemani / 2018-10-03 09:55:52
    In recent findings summarised in the report Delivering Through Diversity by McKinsey & Co. , it emerges that companies with executive gender diversity perform 21% better than less diverse companies. This means that companies with women in top executive roles, where
    Read More
  • Sustainability performance with LCA
    At a recent networking event, I met a very happy sustainability consultant. Given that my new mission in life is to help sustainability consultants to feel happier in their jobs, mainly by making them more confident and able to ‘sell’
    Read More
    • Getting Started
  • How to be assertive in sustainability
    In today’s culture we are all more or less dependent on the pleasure caused by the rush of endorphins that we get when our posts on social media accumulate ‘likes’. Sounds a bit daft when you read it, even childish
    Read More
    • Getting Started
  • Six Sales Techniques for Sustainability Consultants
    You are at your first meeting with a potential new client, and they are clearly not keen on undertaking a sustainability assessment for their building. They have to do it because it’s a planning condition, but really, they would rather
    Read More
    • Your Community